9 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils: Expert-Tested for Natural Definition

Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More Our rankings come from analyzing thousands of customer reviews, looking at factors like product quality, brand reputation, and merchant service. These rankings aim to help guide your shopping choices. By using our recommendations, you'll find the best available prices. We may receive a commission on purchases, at no extra cost to you, which supports our work.

Best Value

2

Revlon

Revlon Eyebrow Kit, ColorStay Brow Kit Eye Makeup with Longwearing Brow Powder, Pomade, Spoolie & Angled Brush Tip, 104 Soft Brown, 0.08 Oz

9.6 Easy to Use

9.5 Long-lasting

9.4 Value for Money

Why we love it

Versatile wet/dry powder formula for natural or dramatic brow looks

Conditioning wax ensures long-lasting hold without residue

Complete kit with dual-ended brush and spoolie for precise application

Main highlights

Key Features

Comprehensive brow kit featuring dual-formula powder, conditioning wax, and professional-grade application tools for customizable eyebrow styling.

Ideal for Creating Professional Brow Looks

Perfect for achieving both natural everyday brows and dramatic defined looks with wet/dry application options and multiple shade choices.

Praised for Versatile Application Options

Users love the flexibility to switch between wet and dry applications, creating various brow styles with long-lasting results.

9.7

Exceptional

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

3

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder BrowPerfect 3D All-In-One Styler with Eyebrow Gel, Pencil & Powder plus Spooled Brush, Warm Blonde

9.5 Long-lasting

9.3 Easy to Apply

9.3 Versatile Design

Why we love it

3-in-1 brow pencil combines pencil, powder, and gel for complete eyebrow styling

24-hour waterproof and transfer-proof formula ensures all-day wear

Micro-precision tip creates natural-looking hair-like strokes

Main highlights

Key Features

Features precision pencil tip, buildable powder application, and clear setting gel for complete brow styling in one convenient tool.

Ideal for achieving professional-looking brows

Perfect for creating natural-looking, long-lasting brows with precise definition and professional finish from home or on-the-go.

Praised for its multi-functional design

Users appreciate the versatile 3-in-1 design that simplifies their brow routine while providing waterproof, fade-resistant results.

9.4

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

4

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Ash Taupe Size 0.003 oz

9.3 Color Accuracy

9.2 Long-lasting

9.0 Easy Application

Why we love it

Three-shade pack offering versatile ash taupe blonde options for natural-looking results

Clean beauty formula free from harmful parabens and mineral oils

Professional matte finish with wax-based staying power

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium wax-based formula delivers three versatile ash taupe shades with paraben-free ingredients and professional matte finish.

Ideal for Professional Hair Color Styling

Perfect for achieving salon-quality blonde highlights and creating dimensional ashy blonde looks with warm undertones.

Praised for Natural-Looking Results

Users consistently praise the natural-looking color gradients and long-lasting matte finish that blends seamlessly with natural hair.

9.2

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

5

CoverGirl

CoverGirl Easy Breezy Brow, Fill+Define Pencils [505] Rich Brown 2 ea ( Pack of 11)

Main highlights

Soft, blendable pencils fill and define brow
Comes with 2 brow pencils and 1 sharpener
Create and shape brows
Product of CoverGirl
Product Packaging May Vary

9.0

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

6

Mac Cosmetics

M.A.C MAC Veluxe Brow Liner - Deep Dark, Brunette, .042 ounce

Main highlights

MAC Veluxe Brow Liner Crayon Sourcils - Deep dark brunette
Country Of Origin: United States
Item Package Dimension: 9.0" L x 6.0" W x 3.0" H
Item Package Weight: 0.4 oz

8.9

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

7

Bobbi Brown

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 5 Espresso by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

8.7 Long-lasting

8.7 Easy to Apply

8.6 Natural Look

Why we love it

Slanted tip for precise application and natural-looking definition

Waterproof formula ensures all-day wear without smudging

Lightweight design with dual-purpose chiseled tip for versatile styling

Main highlights

Key Features

Features a unique slanted tip, waterproof formula, and lightweight design for precise and long-lasting brow definition.

Ideal for everyday brow enhancement

Perfect for busy professionals seeking quick, natural-looking brow enhancement that stays put throughout daily activities.

Praised for its professional-quality results

Users consistently praise its easy application, natural finish, and impressive staying power in various weather conditions.

8.7

Very Good

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

8

Bobbi Brown

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 7 Saddle by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Main highlights

Form: Long Wear Brow Pencil with chiseled tip: This all-in-one, waterproof brow pencil features a slanted, chiseled tip for soft definition to bold structure in a few strokes
Weight: 0.1 ounces: A lightweight yet long-lasting eyebrow pencil that ensures convenience and ease of use
Color: Saddle: Enhance your look with this natural-looking eyebrow pencil shade called 'Saddle'
Application: Step-by-step guide included: Learn how to use the pencil effectively with easy-to-follow instructions
Special feature: Long-lasting and waterproof: This brow pencil guarantees a long-lasting and waterproof finish for a perfect look
Package type: Pencil casing: Comes in a sleek pencil casing for easy storage and portability