Logo Best Reviews Radar
US flag

9 Best Eyebrow Fillers for Natural-Looking Brows – Expert Tested 2025

Fact checked by Isabella Faith
Last Updated January 8, 2025
Editor's Choice
1
Benefit Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Fiber Gel Bundle (Neutral Light Brown, 0.1oz, 2-Pack) (2 Items)

Benefit Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Fiber Gel Bundle (Neutral Light Brown, 0.1oz, 2-Pack) (2 Items)

9.8 Easy to Apply
9.8 Long-lasting
9.6 Natural Look

Why we love it

Water-resistant formula with microfibers for natural-looking volume
Custom tapered brush ensures precise and mess-free application
Buildable tint that adheres to both skin and brow hairs

Main highlights

Key Features

Features a unique combination of microfibers, water-resistant formula, and precision brush for professional-grade brow enhancement.

Ideal for Creating Professional Brow Looks

Perfect for achieving naturally fuller brows, filling sparse areas, and maintaining all-day wear during various activities.

Praised for Effortless Application

Users love the custom tapered brush design that ensures precise application and buildable coverage without mess or clumping.

9.9

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More
Best Value
2
Billion Dollar Brows Universal Eyebrow Pencil | One Perfect Shade | Eyebrow Filler | Smudge Proof | Smooth Application | Easy to Use | Self-Sharpening Tip | Effortless Blending | Vegan & Cruelty-Free

Billion Dollar Brows Universal Eyebrow Pencil | One Perfect Shade | Eyebrow Filler | Smudge Proof | Smooth Application | Easy to Use | Self-Sharpening Tip | Effortless Blending | Vegan & Cruelty-Free

9.7 Easy to Use
9.5 Long-lasting
9.5 Natural Look

Why we love it

Automatic pencil design eliminates need for sharpening and ensures consistent application
Built-in spoolie brush for perfect blending and shaping of eyebrows
Cruelty-free and vegan-friendly formula suitable for all skin tones

Main highlights

Key Features

Features automatic pencil design, dual-ended functionality with spoolie brush, and universal shade matching for all skin tones.

Ideal for daily beauty routines

Perfect for busy individuals seeking quick, professional-looking brow enhancement with minimal effort and maximum impact.

Praised for versatility and convenience

Users love the hassle-free application, natural-looking results, and the convenience of having multiple tools in one product.

9.7

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
3
Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up #6 Rich Brown

Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up #6 Rich Brown

Main highlights

  • Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up #6 Rich Brown

9.4

Excellent

More Deals (1)
4
Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper Rich Brown

Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper Rich Brown

9.5 Easy to Apply
9.5 Natural Look
9.5 Long-lasting

Why we love it

Precision applicator for controlled shaping and filling of eyebrows
Rich brown pigment matches natural hair color seamlessly
Smudge-proof formula stays in place throughout the day

Main highlights

Key Features

Features a precision tip applicator, long-wearing formula, and rich brown pigment for professional-looking brow definition.

Ideal for creating perfectly defined eyebrows

Perfect for daily makeup routines, achieving professional-looking brows, and maintaining a polished appearance throughout the day.

Praised for its natural-looking results

Users love how the rich brown shade blends seamlessly with natural brow hair, creating authentic-looking fuller eyebrows.

9.2

Excellent

More Deals (1)
5
Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up - Mahogany (BNIB)

Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up - Mahogany (BNIB)

9.3 Easy to Apply
9.1 Long-lasting Color
8.9 Natural Looking

Why we love it

Clear gel formula that shapes and sets brows while adding natural-looking color
Buildable color with precise brush applicator for controlled application
Water-resistant formula that lasts throughout the day without flaking

Main highlights

Key Features

Features a dual-purpose formula that shapes brows while depositing rich mahogany color, complete with precision brush for expert application.

Ideal for achieving perfectly groomed eyebrows

Perfect for those seeking to maintain well-groomed brows, fill in sparse areas, and achieve professional-looking results at home.

Praised for its natural-looking finish

Users love how this brow shaper creates natural-looking definition while keeping brows in place all day without stiffness.

9.0

Excellent

More Deals (1)
6
Natural Brow Shaper Mascara - 09 Slate by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.14 oz Mascara

Bobbi Brown

Natural Brow Shaper Mascara - 09 Slate by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.14 oz Mascara

Main highlights

  • Defines and shapes brows
  • Lightweight formula
  • Long-lasting hold
  • Natural-looking finish
  • Easy-to-use brush

8.9

Excellent

More Deals (1)
7
Fab Brows Duo Eyebrow Kit, Ultimate Brow Kit with Compact Powder Mirror and Eyebrow Shaper, Waterproof Eye Makeup Contour Palette Set for Eyebrow, Eyebrow Cosmetics, (Dark Brown/Chocolate Brown)

Fab Brows

Fab Brows Duo Eyebrow Kit, Ultimate Brow Kit with Compact Powder Mirror and Eyebrow Shaper, Waterproof Eye Makeup Contour Palette Set for Eyebrow, Eyebrow Cosmetics, (Dark Brown/Chocolate Brown)

8.9 Easy to Use
8.9 Long-lasting Results
8.8 Professional Quality

Why we love it

Complete kit with 6 reusable stencils and dual-ended brush for professional-looking brows
Water-resistant and smudge-proof formula lasting up to 24 hours
Highly pigmented mineral powder with multiple shade options for natural results

Main highlights

Key Features

Professional-grade eyebrow kit featuring reusable stencils, dual-ended brush, and water-resistant powder for perfect brow shaping and definition.

Ideal for busy women seeking professional brow styling at home

Perfect for daily use, special occasions, and travel, offering quick and easy brow styling with lasting results.

Praised for its user-friendly design and long-lasting results

Customers love the easy-to-follow application process and the long-lasting, natural-looking results that stay perfect throughout the day.

8.7

Very Good

More Deals (1)
8
MADLUVV Eyebrow Stencil Kit - Easy-to-Use, Natural Look, 9 Popular Shapes, Used by Professionals - Includes Stamp, Stencils, Spoolie, and Travel Bag (Brunette)

MADLUVV

MADLUVV Eyebrow Stencil Kit - Easy-to-Use, Natural Look, 9 Popular Shapes, Used by Professionals - Includes Stamp, Stencils, Spoolie, and Travel Bag (Brunette)

Main highlights

  • What It Is – Reduce stress and save time each morning when doing your brows! Each Kit includes one stamp, 9 different stencils, a spoolie to brush through your brows and a cute bag to use for on the go! Now you can achieve perfectly shaped brows in just seconds.
  • Easy To Use – Choose your stencil shape, line up the stencil, and stamp your brow! Clean off the stencil, flip the stencil, and apply the other side. Use the included spoolie to brush and blend your brow! Still have questions? Check out our Brow Stamp tutorial video and FAQ videos on this page!
  • Color in the Cap - The pigment in your Brow Stamp is located inside the cap and not from the sponge applicator. To release the pigment, twist the sponge applicator inside the cap to apply pigment to the top of the sponge. Then remove the color packed cap and use the sponge to apply the color to sparse brows, thinning hair, bald spots, or patchy beards.
  • Why We Luvv It - The brow stamp is designed with the highest quality makeup ingredients with a long-lasting water and sweat resistant formula that goes on smoothly, to both skin and hair, leaving a matte finish. The formula is highly blendable, so it can be applied lighter or darker, depending on the look you want to achieve.
  • How to pick the perfect shape - We have been perfecting our brow shapes for years with the goal of achieving a natural-looking eyebrow shape with minimal effort. Our kits come with 9 of our most popular stencil shapes, all customizable to ensure a perfect shape for your brows. Don't worry, we even throw in a simple Brow Tutorial to show you the perfect shape to pick depending on what you have going on that day!

8.5

Very Good

More Deals (1)
9
5 Pack Temporary Eyebrow Tattoos Waterproof Eyebrow Stickers, False Tattoos Hair Like Peel Off Instant Transfer Brows For Women And Men | Natural Strokes, Shaping (curved, ash brown)

Brows by Bossy

5 Pack Temporary Eyebrow Tattoos Waterproof Eyebrow Stickers, False Tattoos Hair Like Peel Off Instant Transfer Brows For Women And Men | Natural Strokes, Shaping (curved, ash brown)

Main highlights

  • PREMIUM QUALITY EYEBROW TATTOOS - Say goodbye to your old pencil-in brow routine that takes too long and smudges. Our Temporary Brows by Bossy apply in a few simple steps. Instructions, including Application Tips & Tricks, are included. Perfect for sparse, patchy, or over-plucked eyebrows. Give your eyebrows the definition and recognition they deserve! Each brow sheet comes with 9-11 pairs of identical, realistic-sized eyebrow tattoos.

8.4

Very Good

More Deals (1)
Natural Brow Shaper Mascara - 8 Rich Brown by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.14 oz Mascara

Natural Brow Shaper Mascara - 8 Rich Brown by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.14 oz Mascara

$34.00
Madison Reed Root Touch Up + Brow Filler, Terra Medium Brown, Instant Gray Coverage, Fills in Brows & Thinning Hairlines, Temporary Concealing Powder, 0.13 oz (60 uses)

Madison Reed Root Touch Up + Brow Filler, Terra Medium Brown, Instant Gray Coverage, Fills in Brows & Thinning Hairlines, Temporary Concealing Powder, 0.13 oz (60 uses)

$34.00
KIMIKO Fine Eyebrow Pencil Automatique (Twist Up Pencil, Long Wear Formula, Comes with Covered Brush for Natural Looking Brows)

KIMIKO Fine Eyebrow Pencil Automatique (Twist Up Pencil, Long Wear Formula, Comes with Covered Brush for Natural Looking Brows)

$32.00
Babe Original Brow Serum For Thicker Looking Eyebrows - Brow Serum with Peptides, Castor Oil, Biotin, Repairing Amino Acids | 3mL size

Babe Original Brow Serum For Thicker Looking Eyebrows - Brow Serum with Peptides, Castor Oil, Biotin, Repairing Amino Acids | 3mL size

$49.00
LiBrow® Purified Eyebrow Physician-Formulated Serum XL for Fuller & Thicker Looking Eyebrows | Natural Eyebrow Enhancer Safe for Sensitive Skin | 6-Month Supply (6ml)

LiBrow® Purified Eyebrow Physician-Formulated Serum XL for Fuller & Thicker Looking Eyebrows | Natural Eyebrow Enhancer Safe for Sensitive Skin | 6-Month Supply (6ml)

$150.00